Prima facie case in Modvat scrap dispute justified waiver of pre-deposit and stay of recovery.

In a Modvat credit dispute involving alleged non-duty-paid scrap and irregular document issuance, the tribunal considered waiver of pre-deposit on a prima facie basis. It noted that most duty had already been paid, there was no material showing conscious involvement or knowledge of any substitution of scrap, and the record suggested at most a dispute over the nature of scrap received and used. For the dealers, the tribunal found insufficient material to establish that the goods supplied were non-duty-paid or that the invoked provisions applied, and mere mixed scrap or loss of identity was not enough to presume non-payment of duty. Pre-deposit and recovery were therefore waived and stayed.

---

---

Issues: Whether pre-deposit of the disputed duty and penalties should be waived and recovery stayed in a Modvat credit dispute involving alleged non-duty-paid scrap and alleged irregular issuance of documents.

Analysis: The applications were considered on a prima facie basis. As regards the assessee, most of the duty had already been paid and there was nothing to show conscious involvement or knowledge of any substitution of scrap, while the material suggested at best a dispute as to the nature of scrap received and utilised. As regards the dealers, prima facie objections were found concerning lack of opportunity to meet the case, the volume of relied-upon documents, and the absence of sufficient material to establish that the goods supplied were non-duty-paid or that the statutory provisions invoked against them were attracted. Mere presence of mixed scrap or loss of identity of the scrap as CRCA scrap was held insufficient by itself to justify the assumption that duty had not been paid on the goods supplied.

Conclusion: Pre-deposit of the remaining duty and penalties was waived and recovery was stayed.

Ratio Decidendi: In a stay application, where the record discloses a strong prima facie case, absence of conscious involvement, and insufficient material to establish the alleged contravention, pre-deposit and recovery may be waived or stayed.

---