Manufacturing waste classified as plastic waste and scrap when it is neither primary form nor finished plastic film.

PVC waste arising during manufacture, including lumps formed before conversion into film and narrow film-trimming strips, was treated as plastic waste and scrap under Heading 3915 rather than as primary forms or finished plastic film under other headings. Chapter Note 6(a) on primary forms did not apply because the goods were manufacturing waste, not a manufactured plastic product answering the tariff description of film or other finished articles. The classification adopted by the Commissioner (Appeals) was upheld, and the Revenue's contrary classification under Heading 3904 or 3920 was rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether PVC lumps waste and PVC film waste arising during manufacture were classifiable as waste, parings and scrap of plastics under Heading 3915 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, or whether they fell under other tariff headings as primary forms or plastic film.

Analysis: The waste lumps arose during the manufacturing process before conversion of the plastic compound into film and were not a manufactured plastic product in primary form. The film waste consisted only of narrow strips generated by trimming uneven edges of the film rolls and did not answer the description of film or other finished plastic articles. Chapter Note 6(a) dealing with primary forms did not govern such manufacturing waste, and the goods were treated as waste emerging at different stages of production. The classification adopted by the Commissioner (Appeals) was consistent with the earlier tribunal view relied upon in the order.

Conclusion: The waste goods were correctly classified under Heading 3915 as plastic waste and scrap, and the Revenue's classification under Heading 3904 or Heading 3920 was rejected.

Final Conclusion: The appeal failed and the classification in favour of the assessee was affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi: Waste arising at different stages of manufacture, which is not itself a primary form or a finished article answering the tariff description of film, is classifiable as plastic waste and scrap under Heading 3915.

---