Rebuttable transit-pass presumption under sales tax law requires fresh reconsideration of both tax assessment and penalty

The transit-pass mechanism under section 28AA of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act treats non-delivery of the pass within time as giving rise to a rebuttable presumption of intra-State sale and consequent assessment, while penalty is confined to failure to deliver the pass as required. Where the tax issue has already been remitted for fresh consideration, the connected penalty cannot be retained independently; both tax and penalty must be reconsidered by the assessing authority, and the merits remain open.

---

---

Issues: Whether the levy of tax and penalty under section 28AA of the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957 could stand when the matter required reconsideration, and whether the matter should be remitted for fresh decision.

Analysis: The transit-pass mechanism under section 28AA treats non-delivery of the pass within the stipulated time as giving rise to a presumption of intra-State sale and consequent assessment, while the penalty provision authorises imposition only in relation to failure to deliver the transit pass as required. The High Court had already remitted the tax issue for fresh consideration after holding that the statutory presumption was rebuttable. In the circumstances, the penalty finding could not be retained independently and both tax and penalty required reconsideration by the assessing authority in accordance with law. The parties' contentions on merits were left open before the check-post officer.

Conclusion: The levy of penalty was set aside and the matter was remitted for fresh decision on both tax and penalty under section 28AA, with all merits left open.

Final Conclusion: The dispute was sent back to the assessing authority for fresh adjudication, and no final determination on the tax liability or penalty was made by the Court in this order.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the foundational assessment under the transit-pass provision is remitted for fresh decision, the connected penalty cannot be finally sustained and both issues must be reconsidered by the statutory authority.

---