Modvat credit requires proper RG 23A entries and proof of receipt and use of inputs in manufacture.

Modvat credit was held inadmissible where the assessee entered the credit only in RG 23A Part II without the corresponding entry in Part I and without proof of receipt and consumption of the goods in manufacture. The scheme under Rule 57G(7) required maintenance of both registers, and the omission in Part I was not shown to be a mere clerical error. Earlier decisions were distinguished because they involved substantive compliance with only a mistaken register entry. The demand confirmed by the lower authorities was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether Modvat credit could be retained when the assessee had entered the credit only in RG 23A Part-II without making the corresponding entry in Part-I and without proof of receipt and consumption of the goods in manufacture.

Analysis: The relevant scheme required maintenance of RG 23A Parts I and II under Rule 57G(7) of the Central Excise Rules, 1944. The omission in Part-I was not shown to be a mere oversight or clerical mistake. The assessee also failed to produce proof that the goods were actually received in the factory and consumed in the manufacture of final products. The earlier decisions relied upon were distinguishable because they involved substantive compliance and only a mistaken omission in the statutory register.

Conclusion: Modvat credit was not admissible, and the demand confirmed by the lower authorities was upheld.

---