Reasoned writ orders are required to satisfy natural justice and enable effective appellate review

A writ court is bound to give reasons when dismissing or rejecting a writ petition, because recording reasons is part of fair administration of justice and the requirements of natural justice. Where the writ order affects rights and an appeal lies, the parties and the appellate court must be able to understand the basis of the decision. A bare order such as "dismissed" or "rejected" is insufficient, although the reasons may be brief rather than detailed.

---

---

Issues: Whether a writ court is under an obligation to pass a speaking order recording reasons while dismissing or rejecting a writ petition.

Analysis: Recording reasons is an essential requirement of fair and equitable administration of justice and is part of the requirements of natural justice. Where a writ order affects rights and an appeal lies, reasons are necessary so that the parties and the appellate court can know the basis of the decision. A laconic order such as "dismissed" or "rejected" does not satisfy this standard, though the reasons need not be lengthy and may be stated briefly.

Conclusion: The writ court is bound to pass a speaking order recording relevant reasons while disposing of a writ petition.

---