Excise valuation dispute: prima facie defence accepted for CST component, but freight and receivables claims lacked evidence.

In an interim excise valuation dispute, inclusion of 4% recovered towards Central Sales Tax, post-manufacturing charges and incidental charges raised a prima facie case only in part: the railway letter showing no sales tax payment to the assessee supported a defence on the CST component, but the plea for deduction of freight and interest on receivables was not backed by evidence. The invoices' description as incidental charges, PMC/Freight was treated as too vague to conclude that officers were necessarily alerted to the true nature of the amounts, and the extended period issue under Section 11A was not decisively negated at this stage. Pre-deposit was ordered, with the balance duty, penalties and fine stayed on compliance.

---

---

Issues: Whether the demand based on inclusion of 4% recovered towards Central Sales Tax, post-manufacturing charges and incidental charges in the assessable value disclosed a prima facie case for waiver of pre-deposit; whether the plea regarding deduction of freight and interest on receivables was supported; and whether the extended period of limitation under the proviso to Section 11A was invocable.

Analysis: The letter from the railway authorities indicating that no sales tax amount had been paid to the assessee for the relevant period furnished a prima facie defence in respect of the CST-related demand. The plea that freight and interest on receivables would exceed the amount sought to be added was not supported by evidence, since there was nothing to show that the sale price included freight or that the price included interest for two months. The description in the invoices as incidental charges, PMC/Freight was held to be vague, and at the interim stage it could not be said that the departmental officers ought necessarily to have been alerted to the true nature of the amounts.

Outcome: Pre-deposit of Rs. 6 lakhs was directed, and on such deposit the balance duty, penalties and fine were waived and recovery stayed.

---