How do Indian Credit Rating Agencies Work?

Indian credit rating agencies (CRAs) play a vital role in the financial ecosystem by assessing the creditworthiness of entities such as companies, financial institutions, governments, and debt instruments (e.g., bonds, debentures). These agencies provide opinions (credit ratings) that help investors, lenders, and regulators make informed decisions.

🔹 Key Credit Rating Agencies in India

1. CRISIL (Credit Rating Information Services of India Ltd.)
2. ICRA (originally Investment Information and Credit Rating Agency)
3. CARE Ratings (Credit Analysis and Research Limited)
4. India Ratings and Research (subsidiary of Fitch)
5. Brickwork Ratings
6. SMERA (now Acuité Ratings)

All these are registered with SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India), which regulates their functioning.

🔹 How Credit Rating Agencies Work in India

1. Rating Mandate

• The process begins when an issuer (company, bank, NBFC, government body) approaches a CRA to get a credit rating for its debt instrument or itself.
• A rating agreement is signed, which includes confidentiality clauses, fees, and cooperation clauses.

2. Data Collection

• The issuer provides detailed information including:
  • Financial statements (audited)
  • Business plans and projections
  • Industry reports
  • Loan and debt details
  • Management profile
  • Operational data (production, capacity, utilization, etc.)

3. Analytical Evaluation

CRAs evaluate the entity using both quantitative and qualitative factors:

✅ Quantitative Analysis:

• Financial ratios (leverage, liquidity, profitability, coverage)
• Historical financial performance
• Cash flow projections
• Capital structure and debt service obligations

✅ Qualitative Analysis:

• Industry risk and competition
• Regulatory environment
• Management quality and corporate governance
• Legal structures and contractual protections (e.g., guarantees, covenants)
• Business model and diversification

4. Rating Committee Review

• A rating committee of senior analysts and industry experts reviews the analysis.
• This committee discusses all aspects and assigns a rating based on standardized criteria.
• The rating reflects the probability of default and credit risk associated with the issuer or instrument.

5. Rating Communication & Acceptance

• The assigned rating is communicated to the issuer.
• The issuer can:
  • Accept the rating, and it becomes public.
  • Appeal the rating, leading to a review.
  • Not accept, in which case the rating may not be published (unless required by regulation).

6. Publication of Rating

• Once accepted, the rating is published on the agency’s website and disclosed through press releases.
• This includes a rating rationale explaining the key factors behind the rating decision.

7. Surveillance and Review

• Ratings are not permanent. Agencies conduct periodic surveillance (typically quarterly or annually).
• Ratings can be upgraded, downgraded, or reaffirmed based on updated data and performance.
• If an issuer defaults or is likely to default, the rating is reviewed immediately.

🔹 Rating Scale Example (for long-term instruments)

(Prefixes like 'CRISIL', 'CARE', or 'ICRA' are used, e.g., CRISIL AA, ICRA BBB.)

🔹 Regulatory Oversight

• SEBI regulates CRAs under the SEBI (Credit Rating Agencies) Regulations, 1999.
• CRAs must follow transparency, disclosure norms, and maintain confidentiality and independence.

***