Reply - show cause notice

[BAL KRISHAN GARG]

Respected Rama Krishna Ji , First of all I want to give thanks for your early reply vide ID NO. 1556 . Here I reproducing the letter as under for your kind consideration : DATE : 22/10/2009 The Asstt.Commissioner of Service Tax , DIVISION – I , RANGE – II , 37, IInd Floor, Near Ansal Tower, Nehru Place , NEW DELHI – 110019 ------------------------------ Case : M/S Afreen Coats, F-3/15 ,Sector -16 , Rohini ,Delhi - 85 -------------------- Subject: Reply to Show Cause Notice dt. NIL issued by Asstt. Commissioner ---------------------------- Ref.: C.No. DL – I/ST/R – II / SOF / MEPL /42/08 -------------------------------- We acknowledge the receipt of above Show Cause Notice dt. Nil on 30th Sep.,2009 . Sir , Some information and documents are still pending from M/S Marc Enterprises (P) Ltd. i.e. Recipient of the Services and it will take some time further and as all these are to enclosed with the reply of the above referred SCN . Keeping the above facts in mind , I request to grant me some time to file the reply and most Probably it will be submitted by 30th November ,2009 .However ,an opportunity of personal hearing may be granted before passing an order in this regard. Kindly consider my inability to submit the reply without enclosers explained above and allow me to file the same by 30th November ,09 and oblidge . Thanking You , For AFREEN COATS , ( PUTUL ANAM ) Further Sir , there are two other job workers to whom the SCN were issued in this regard but could not be delivered due to old address . Whether these two SCN's are advisable from your angel to receive through me from the Division itself and whether this will help us in defending in Appeal and Tribunal and to what extent ? and whether the new address may be given in writing in this regard ? Sir , I will be highly oblidged to you .

[Rama Krishana]

Your letter seems to be okay. Regarding change in address and receipt of SCN through consultant, I would like to say that it is more technical and practicle problem. The solution would depend on many factors which are pre and post to the event. Therefore, I am unable to express my view on this issue.

AI Summary

Show cause notice response: request for extension to file reply and for a personal hearing before adjudication. Acknowledges receipt of a service tax show cause notice and requests an extension to file the reply because essential documents from the service recipient are pending; asks for a personal hearing before any order is passed. Also inquires whether two undelivered notices can be received through the applicant or a consultant and whether a written change of address would aid appellate defensibility; adviser concurs on the extension request but cannot opine on the address/receipt issue due to technical dependencies.