TCS on sales if payment received in next financial year

[Ashish Gupta]

Dear Sir,

Most of the people are charging TCS on Sales in the Sales Invoice. TCS on Sales is based on payment collection. If Sales happens in say March 2021 wherein TCS is charged in the invoice and payment is done say in May, how is TCS on Sales collected in such case?

Since TCS is already charged in invoice in March, it will need to be paid. Also since TCS is based on collection, again compliance issue might come as TCS again becomes payable.

26AS will also become complicated as party to party different systems are followed as some charge TCS on collection and some in the invoice

[Ganeshan Kalyani]

Sir, in my view, TCS is payable at the time of receipt of payment. The convenient way adopted by some taxpayer is to charge TCS on sale invoice. However, department will demand the tax only as per law. So, a reconciliation is a must to prove correct tax has been paid.

[DR.MARIAPPAN GOVINDARAJAN]

Whether TCS, in your query, is in relation to Income Tax Act or GST Act?

[Ashish Gupta]

I am asking in relation to Income Tax

[DR.MARIAPPAN GOVINDARAJAN]

Ok I will revert

[DR.MARIAPPAN GOVINDARAJAN]

In my view as Ganesan said it should be paid on collection of bill only. So you have to pay only on May.

whether you have paid the tax on March itself?

[CASusheel Gupta]

Since TCS is not collected till March end, no liability to deposit. Simply show it as TCS not yet Collected in balance sheet and in next year deposit the amount on collection.

CA Susheel Gupta

[Ganesh S]

An additional aspect to be considered is the TCS so collected in the sales invoice might be at a lesser rate prescribed until March 31st 2021. If the payment is received in next year when the TCS rate is at normal rate, the differential tax needs to be collected as the TCS is on collection of sale consideration and not on invoicing.

AI Summary

Clarification on Timing of TCS Payments: Payable Upon Payment Receipt, Not Invoice Issuance; Address Rate Changes Yearly A discussion was held regarding the timing of Tax Collected at Source (TCS) payments when sales occur in one financial year and payments are received in the next. The initial query raised concerns about the compliance issues arising from charging TCS on sales invoices versus upon payment collection. Replies highlighted that TCS is technically payable upon receipt of payment, though some businesses charge it on invoices for convenience. It was suggested to reconcile accounts to ensure correct tax payment. Additionally, if TCS rates change between financial years, any differential tax must be addressed upon payment collection.