Regional price differential in excise valuation upheld where depot sales reflected genuine commercial conditions and no extra consideration was shown.

Different assessable values for depot clearances were accepted where regional prices reflected genuine commercial factors such as competition, taxation, freight and market conditions, and there was no evidence of extra consideration or a sham arrangement. The valuation principle applied was that more than one normal price may exist when wholesale sales are made to non-related buyers for price alone and valid business reasons explain the regional differential. Depot sales were treated as an extension of the factory gate for the concerned region, so the higher factory gate value was not the proper basis for assessment. The lower assessable value for Guwahati depot sales was upheld and the duty demand on the higher value failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether, for clearances to the Guwahati region through depot sales, a lower assessable value based on regional market conditions and commercial considerations could be accepted under the excise valuation provisions.

Analysis: The assessee had maintained different declared prices for different regions and there was no allegation or evidence of extra consideration flowing back or of the Guwahati prices being sham. The regional price differential was supported by commercial factors such as competition, taxation, freight and market conditions. The decisions relied upon showed that where buyers in different regions or classes are treated differently for valid commercial reasons, more than one normal price may exist, provided the sale is in wholesale trade, the buyer is not a related person, and price is the sole consideration. The attempt to distinguish depot sales from direct factory gate sales was rejected, since depot sales were treated as an extension of the factory gate where no factory gate clearance for that region existed.

Conclusion: The lower assessable value for Guwahati depot sales was upheld and the demand based on the higher factory gate value did not survive.

---