Conditional deposit in stay proceedings enabled merits hearing where small-scale exemption and MODVAT credit were claimed.

The Tribunal considered whether an appeal earlier dismissed for non-deposit could proceed on merits in a stay matter. It found a prima facie case based on the claim to small-scale exemption under Notification No. 175/86 and the asserted valid availment of MODVAT credit on previously declared inputs, but held that the factual position still required examination by the Collector (Appeals). To enable the appeal to be heard, conditional relief was granted by directing a cash deposit of Rs. 20,000; upon compliance, the Collector (Appeals)' order would stand vacated and the appeal would be taken on record for decision on merits.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appeal could be taken up on merits despite the earlier dismissal for non-deposit and what conditional relief, if any, should be granted in the stay matter.

Analysis: The applicants claimed small-scale exemption under Notification No. 175/86 and contended that MODVAT credit had been validly availed on inputs already declared earlier. The Tribunal noted a prima facie case in their favour, but also observed that the factual position required examination by the Collector (Appeals) on merits. In view of the financial position and for enabling the appeal to be heard, a conditional deposit was directed.

Conclusion: The applicants were directed to deposit Rs. 20,000 in cash, after which the order of the Collector (Appeals) would stand vacated and the appeal would be taken on record for decision on merits.

---