Public charitable trust cannot enlarge its settlement by later gifts absent trust deed authority; dividend refund claim failed.

A public charitable trust cannot enlarge the original settlement by accepting a further gift of shares unless the trust deed authorises such augmentation. The court noted that the gift was complete between the parties because the trustees accepted it on the donor's terms, but it did not become part of the original trust for tax purposes. As a result, dividend income from those shares was not treated as trust income, and the trust could not claim refund of tax deducted at source on that income. The assessee's claims therefore failed, and the revenue's position was upheld.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the gift of shares made by a trustee was valid and complete in law but operated to augment the existing public charitable trust; (ii) whether the assessee trust was entitled to refund of tax deducted at source on dividends accruing on the gifted shares.

Issue (i): Whether the gift of shares made by a trustee was valid and complete in law but operated to augment the existing public charitable trust.

Analysis: The transfer of shares was accepted by the trustees on the donor's terms, so the gift was complete as between the parties. However, the trust deed did not confer any general power on the trustees to accept further gifts, donations, or endowments so as to enlarge the original settlement. A public charitable trust is bound by the scope of the deed creating it, unless the deed itself authorises augmentation by subsequent gifts. On that footing, the gifted shares could not be treated as having become part of the original trust for taxation purposes.

Conclusion: The gift was valid and complete, but it did not augment the assessee trust.

Issue (ii): Whether the assessee trust was entitled to refund of tax deducted at source on dividends accruing on the gifted shares.

Analysis: Since the gifted shares did not become an accretion to the original trust, the dividend income arising from them could not be treated as income of the assessee trust for the purpose of claiming refund under the exemption provision. The assessee's claim for refund therefore failed.

Conclusion: The assessee was not entitled to refund of tax deducted at source on the dividend income from the gifted shares.

Final Conclusion: The reference was answered against the assessee on both questions, and the revenue's position was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: A public charitable trust cannot, in the absence of authority in the trust deed, enlarge the original trust by accepting subsequent gifts so as to claim tax exemption on the resulting income as part of that trust.

---