Vocational gifts taxable when directly linked to preaching services and not exempt as casual non-recurring receipts.

A receipt of land under a deed of gift was treated as taxable income because the gift was directly referable to the assessee's vocation as a religious teacher. The deed recorded that the donor had received spiritual benefit from years of preaching, and the transfer was made in consideration of those benefits, affection and veneration for the teacher. On those facts, the value of the land arose from the exercise of a vocation and could not be treated as a casual or non-recurring receipt exempt under section 4(3)(vii) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922. Authorities dealing with ordinary personal gifts and burden of proof did not alter that result.

---

---

Issues: Whether the value of land received by the assessee under the deed of gift dated 6 December 1957 was a receipt arising from the assessee's vocation as a religious teacher and was therefore taxable, or whether it was a casual and non-recurring gift exempt from tax.

Analysis: The assessment year was 1958-59. The deed of gift expressly recorded that the donee had preached the cult to the donor for years, that the donor had derived mental enlightenment and spiritual benefit from that preaching, and that the gift was made in consideration of those benefits and the affection and veneration felt for the spiritual teacher. On those findings, the receipt was directly traceable to the assessee's vocation as a preacher of the Satsang cult. A receipt arising from the exercise of a profession, vocation or occupation does not fall within the exemption for casual and non-recurring receipts under section 4(3)(vii) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922. The authorities below were therefore right in treating the value of the land as part of the assessee's income. The cited authorities concerning personal gifts and the burden of proof did not assist the assessee on these facts.

Conclusion: The receipt was taxable income arising from the assessee's vocation and not an exempt casual gift.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a gift is made in consideration of benefits derived from the assessee's professional or vocational activities and is directly referable to those activities, its value is income arising from the vocation and is not exempt as a casual or non-recurring receipt.

---