Share broker allowed bad debt deduction on client receivables; entire debit balance qualifies under sections 36(1)(vii) and 36(2)

HC held that in a share broking business, amounts receivable from clients for purchase/sale of shares constitute a "debt" for purposes of section 36(1)(vii). The fact that only brokerage was credited to the profit and loss account does not convert the underlying share transaction into an investment by the assessee. Since the assessee treated the transaction as one of brokerage on behalf of clients and the brokerage component had been considered in computing income, the entire debit balance, including sale/purchase consideration, qualifies as bad debt once it becomes irrecoverable. The statutory conditions under section 36(2) were satisfied, and the assessee was entitled to the bad debt deduction. The Revenue's appeal was dismissed.

---

---

Issues: Whether, under Section 36(1)(vii) read with Section 36(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the total debit balance including the consideration collectible by a broker for purchase/sale of shares (beyond brokerage credited in profit and loss account) can be claimed as a bad debt when the broker has only credited brokerage as income.

Analysis: The Court examined whether amounts paid by the assessee-broker on behalf of clients constitute a "debt" and whether the conditions in Section 36(2) are satisfied when brokerage has been taken to income. The Court followed the Delhi High Court decision in CIT v. Morgan Securities and Credits P. Ltd. and consistent Tribunal decisions which held that where brokerage (being part of the receivable) has been taken into account in computing income, the entire receivable including the purchase/sale consideration payable by the client is to be treated as debt. The Court rejected the Revenue's contention that payment by the broker makes the transaction an investment by the broker and that the shortfall is a capital loss, noting that the assessee treated the transaction as brokerage business and had declared brokerage as income; thus the unpaid balance is revenue receivable and became irrecoverable.

Conclusion: The unpaid consideration payable by the client is a "debt" and, having become irrecoverable, qualifies as a "bad debt" under Section 36(1)(vii) read with Section 36(2). The question of law is decided against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee.

---