Assessable value includes inflated ancillary charges treated as additional consideration for excisable goods

Charges recovered towards cylinder rental, repair, maintenance, testing and freight were treated as part of the assessable value of oxygen gas where the collections exceeded actual expenditure and were also levied on customers supplying their own cylinders. On those facts, the amounts were not accepted as mere reimbursable or equalised charges. The earlier exclusion of cylinder rental on different facts was distinguished, and the operative principle applied was that artificially inflated ancillary charges, when they constitute additional consideration for the sale of excisable goods, form part of assessable value for duty purposes.

---

---

Issues: Whether amounts recovered towards cylinder rental, repair, maintenance, testing and freight, when charged in excess of actual expenditure and even from customers supplying their own cylinders, were includible in the assessable value of oxygen gas.

Analysis: The amounts recovered under the various heads were found to be far in excess of the actual expenditure and were also charged from buyers who brought their own cylinders, where no corresponding cylinder-related service was being rendered. On these facts, the claim that the collections were mere reimbursable or equalised charges was rejected. The earlier view excluding cylinder rental on different facts was distinguished, and the principle applied was that where charges are artificially inflated and are in substance additional consideration flowing from the buyer to the assessee, they form part of the assessable value.

Conclusion: The impugned charges were held includible in the assessable value, and the assessee's challenge failed.

Final Conclusion: The appeal was rejected because the disputed cylinder-related collections were treated as part of the value of the excisable goods for duty purposes.

Ratio Decidendi: Charges recovered from customers in the guise of ancillary services are includible in assessable value when the evidence shows that they are artificially inflated and constitute additional consideration for the sale of excisable goods.

---