Capital receipt on premature termination excluded from tax, while accrued managing agency remuneration remained taxable on these facts.

A payment of Rs. 60,000 received on premature termination of a consultancy arrangement is treated as capital in nature and not taxable, where the receipt is in settlement of the termination and the earlier year's finding already characterised it as capital. By contrast, managing agency remuneration accrued for services already rendered remains taxable in the relevant assessment year, because the amounts arose on approval of the company accounts and the taxpayer had not shown a permanent discontinuance of business. The cited principle on discontinued professional practice was therefore inapplicable, and the statutory insertion dealing with post-discontinuance receipts did not alter the result on these facts.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the amount of Rs. 60,000 received on termination of the consultancy arrangement was a capital receipt not chargeable to tax; (ii) Whether the balance of managing agency remuneration received during the relevant previous year was taxable for the assessment year 1971-72 notwithstanding the discontinuance of the managing agency business.

Issue (i): Whether the amount of Rs. 60,000 received on termination of the consultancy arrangement was a capital receipt not chargeable to tax.

Analysis: The amount was received in settlement for premature termination of the consultancy arrangement. The Tribunal had already held, in the assessment proceedings for the earlier year, that the receipt was on capital account and not taxable under the business provisions. That finding governed the present year as well.

Conclusion: The receipt of Rs. 60,000 was a capital receipt and was not taxable in the assessment year under consideration.

Issue (ii): Whether the balance of managing agency remuneration received during the relevant previous year was taxable for the assessment year 1971-72 notwithstanding the discontinuance of the managing agency business.

Analysis: The sums represented remuneration for services already rendered as managing agents and accrued when the company accounts were approved during the relevant previous year. The assessee had not shown that it had gone out of business permanently and had in fact continued corporate and business activity. The principle in the cited authority on discontinued professional practice did not apply because the assessee had not permanently ceased business. The subsequent statutory insertion concerning receipts after discontinuance did not alter the position on these facts.

Conclusion: The balance of managing agency remuneration was taxable in the assessment year 1971-72.

Final Conclusion: The assessment was required to be modified by excluding the compensation of Rs. 60,000 while including the managing agency remuneration accrued and received in the relevant previous year.

Ratio Decidendi: A receipt for premature termination of a commercial arrangement is not taxable where it is capital in nature, but remuneration accrued for services already rendered remains taxable in the year of accrual or receipt if the taxpayer has not permanently discontinued business.

---