Input credit for repair-related welding materials linked to plant maintenance and continuous manufacturing

Welding electrodes, oxygen gas and acetylene gas used to weld punctured pipes carrying hot sugar juice were treated as inputs used in or in relation to manufacture, because the welding activity maintained the plant in working condition and enabled continuous production. The Tribunal preferred the later understanding that maintenance and overhauling of machinery can form an integral part of the manufacturing process, rather than a narrower view excluding repair-related use. The text also indicates reliance on the broader meaning of the expression, but the supplied extract ends before the full principle is stated.

---

---

Issues: Whether welding electrodes, oxygen gas and acetylene gas used for welding punctured pipes carrying hot sugar juice were eligible inputs as being used in or in relation to the manufacture of the final product.

Analysis: The inputs were used for welding punctured pipes and maintaining the plant in working condition so that production could continue effectively. The reasoning in earlier Tribunal precedent denying credit for repair and maintenance was found to be inconsistent with the later understanding that maintenance and overhauling of machinery can be an integral part of the manufacturing process. The Tribunal also relied on the broader principle that the expression

---