Tariff classification of plastic shelves favours household articles of plastics over furniture under Chapter 94.

Plastic shelves used on bathroom platforms, kitchen platforms and table tops are classifiable as household articles of plastics under Heading 3924.90, not as furniture under Heading 94.03. The Tribunal applied the HSN Explanatory Notes to Chapter 94 and held that furniture does not extend to articles designed for placement on other furniture, shelves, walls or ceilings, including small furnishing goods of plastics. It also treated the goods by their popular and commercial understanding, noted that they were not trolleys, and distinguished the earlier trolley decision as factually different and inconsistent with the HSN guidance.

---

---

Issues: Whether plastic shelves used on bathroom platforms, kitchen platforms and table tops are classifiable under Chapter Heading 3924.90 as household articles of plastics or under Chapter Heading 94.03 as furniture.

Analysis: The Tribunal compared the competing tariff entries and applied the HSN Explanatory Notes to Chapter 94. The reasoning accepted that furniture under Chapter 94 does not extend to articles designed for placing on other furniture, shelves, walls or ceilings, and specifically noted the exclusion of small furnishing goods and office equipment of plastics. On the evidence, the products in dispute were plastic shelves without wheels, not trolleys, and were used for keeping small household and toilet articles on table tops, kitchen platforms and bathroom platforms. The earlier decision in relation to trolleys was distinguished because it concerned materially different goods and did not adequately consider the HSN guidance. The Tribunal also preferred popular and commercial understanding of the product over dictionary meaning.

Conclusion: The plastic shelves are properly classifiable under Heading 3924.90 and not under Heading 94.03; the reference is answered in favour of the respondent.

Final Conclusion: The correct tariff classification of the goods in question was determined to be as household articles of plastics, and the contrary view treating them as furniture was rejected for these goods.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods designed for placement on table tops, kitchen platforms or bathroom platforms for keeping small articles are excluded from the tariff concept of furniture under Chapter 94 and are classifiable as household articles of plastics under Chapter 39.

---