Export value misdeclaration is actionable under customs law even when no export duty is payable.

Over-invoicing of export goods is treated as an offence under the Customs Act, and exporters must make a truthful declaration of value in the shipping bill. The customs valuation framework applies to export consignments even where no export duty is leviable, so customs authorities are not bound to accept the declared FOB value if the record shows misdeclaration or over-invoicing. Earlier views excluding duty-free exports from the reach of valuation under Section 14 were rejected as inconsistent with the statutory scheme. Confiscation and penalty based on over-invoicing and misdeclaration of export value were sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether over-invoicing of export goods is an offence under the Customs Act, 1962 and whether the customs authorities can determine the value of export goods under Section 14 even when no export duty is chargeable.

Analysis: The statutory scheme requires an exporter to present a shipping bill and make a truthful declaration of the particulars, including value, in the prescribed form. The expression "value" in the Customs Act is linked to Section 14(1), and the same meaning applies to export consignments when value is required to be declared. The reasoning accepted that valuation for export is not confined to cases where customs duty is leviable, and that customs authorities are not bound to accept the declared FOB value if the record discloses over-invoicing or misdeclaration. The earlier views treating duty-free export goods as outside Section 14 were examined and rejected, and the contrary view was held inconsistent with the statutory scheme and the authoritative decisions relied upon.

Conclusion: Over-invoicing of export goods is an offence under the Customs Act, 1962, and the customs authorities are entitled to test the declared export value under Section 14(1) even where the goods are not chargeable to export duty.

Final Conclusion: The appeal fails, and the confiscation and penalty imposed on the basis of over-invoicing and misdeclaration of export value are sustained.

Ratio Decidendi: For export goods, the declaration of value is governed by the customs valuation framework, and customs authorities may determine the correctness of the declared value under Section 14(1) irrespective of whether the goods are themselves dutiable.

---