Factory-gate price to independent buyers can determine excise value when related-party sales are at the same price without special favour.

Where excisable goods are sold at the same factory-gate price to a related subsidiary and to substantial numbers of independent buyers, the price to independent buyers may be adopted as the assessable value under section 4(1)(a) of the Central Excise and Salt Act, 1944. The decisive factor is the absence of any special favour, preferential pricing, or extra-commercial consideration in sales to the related buyer. On that footing, the valuation based on the independent buyer price was upheld and the challenge to the duty demand failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether, for valuation of excisable goods sold partly to a related subsidiary and partly to independent buyers, the price charged to independent buyers at the factory gate could form the basis of assessable value under section 4(1)(a) of the Central Excise and Salt Act, 1944.

Analysis: The sales to unrelated buyers constituted a substantial part of the total clearances during the relevant periods. The goods were sold to the related subsidiary at the same price at which they were sold to other buyers, and no special consideration or preferential treatment in pricing was shown. In these circumstances, the price charged to independent buyers represented the proper basis for determining value under the excise valuation provision.

Conclusion: The assessable value was rightly determined on the basis of the price charged to independent buyers, and the challenge to the duty demand failed.

Final Conclusion: The appeals were rejected and the valuation adopted by the authorities below was sustained.

Ratio Decidendi: Where excisable goods are sold at the same factory-gate price to a related person and to substantial numbers of independent buyers, the price to independent buyers may be taken as the assessable value in the absence of any special favour or extra-commercial consideration.

---