Appeals dismissed as identical legal issues already decided by Division Bench in 2009 precedent case

The Bombay HC dismissed two appeals after finding no substantial question of law arose, as identical issues had been previously decided by the Division Bench in a 2009 case. The Court determined the matters did not warrant further consideration given the existing precedent and dismissed both appeals without costs.

---

---

The Bombay High Court, in an order by V.C. Daga and J.P. Devadhar, dismissed two appeals raising identical questions previously decided by the Division Bench in Income Tax Appeal No. 165 of 2009 (The Commissioner of Income Tax v. Star India P. Ltd.) by order dated 24/3/2009. The Court held that "no substantial question of law arise in these appeals," resulting in dismissal of both appeals with no order as to costs.

---