Octroi valuation on imported goods includes customs duty at entry, and later concessional duty does not justify refund

Octroi on imported goods entering Greater Bombay was chargeable on the value at the point of entry for consumption, use or sale, and the municipal rules required customs duty incurred or liable to be incurred to be included in that valuation. Later payment of only concessional customs duty after removal from a bonded warehouse did not alter the assessable value fixed on import. Refund was available only for wrongful or excessive recovery, and that basis was not made out because the levy followed the Bills of Entry and the accepted customs value at entry.

---

---

Issues: Whether octroi could be levied by including the provisional customs duty in the value of imported goods brought into Greater Bombay and whether refund was admissible when the importer later paid only concessional customs duty.

Analysis: Octroi under the municipal law became chargeable on entry of the goods into Greater Bombay for consumption, use or sale, and the value for ad valorem levy was to be determined at that point of entry. The relevant octroi rules required inclusion of customs duty incurred or liable to be incurred, but the later actual payment of reduced or concessional customs duty after removal from the bonded warehouse did not alter the value as on the date of import. Refund under the rules was confined to cases of wrongful or excessive recovery, which was not established here because the levy was made on the basis of the Bills of Entry and the accepted customs value at the time of entry.

Conclusion: The refusal to refund octroi was upheld and the petitions failed.

---