Tax Appeal Outcome: Treatment of Waived Machinery Purchase Amount as Taxable Business Benefit

The appeal was partly allowed, directing the Assessing Officer to consider the exchange rate at the date of receipt of equipment for converting US$ 3,66,000 into Rupees. The waiver of US$ 3,66,000 for purchasing machinery was deemed taxable under section 28(iv) as a business benefit, while the waiver of US$ 500,000 cash loan was excluded from taxable income. The order was pronounced on 31st March 2023.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Opportunity of being heard.
2. Addition on account of waiver of loan as business income.
3. Waiver of loan for acquiring plant and machinery.
4. Adoption of exchange rate for loan waiver.

Summary:

1. Opportunity of Being Heard:
The Assessee contended that the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) ['CIT(A)'] erred in passing the order without providing an opportunity of being heard. However, the Assessee later chose not to press this ground, and it was dismissed as not pressed.

2. Addition on Account of Waiver of Loan as Business Income:
The Assessee argued that the CIT(A) wrongly confirmed the addition of INR 3,63,72,000 (correct amount INR 2,75,00,000) as business income under section 28(iv) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, instead of treating it as a capital receipt. The Tribunal held that the waiver of US$ 3,66,000, which was the purchase price of machinery, constituted a benefit arising from business and was taxable under section 28(iv). However, the waiver of the cash loan of US$ 500,000 was not considered income under section 28(iv) following the Supreme Court's decision in the Mahindra & Mahindra case.

3. Waiver of Loan for Acquiring Plant and Machinery:
The Assessee submitted that INR 1,53,72,000 was waived for acquiring plant and machinery and should be treated as a capital receipt. The Tribunal found that the amount of US$ 3,66,000 was not a loan but a business liability for the purchase of plant and machinery. The waiver of this amount was taxable under section 28(iv) as it provided a business benefit.

4. Adoption of Exchange Rate for Loan Waiver:
The Assessee contended that the total amount of loan waiver should be INR 2,75,00,000, based on the exchange rate at the date of receipt of equipment, not the date of waiver. The Tribunal directed the Assessing Officer to consider the exchange rate applicable on the date of receipt of the equipment for converting US$ 3,66,000 into Rupees. This ground was allowed for statistical purposes.

Order:
The appeal was partly allowed, with specific directions to the Assessing Officer regarding the exchange rate for the loan waiver and the exclusion of the cash loan waiver from taxable income under section 28(iv). The decision was pronounced on 31st March 2023.

---