Imported goods classification turned on laboratory retest, leading to release of seized balance quantity with inquiry safeguards.

Authoritative retest of the remnant samples showed the imported cargo to be liquid paraffin of the declared class, and not Light Diesel Oil; on that basis, continued seizure was not justified on mere suspicion. The Court also noted that the goods formed part of a commingled import and that comparable consignments of another importer had already been released. Balance seizure was therefore ordered to be lifted on undertaking and cooperation with the inquiry, while the customs investigation and departmental rights were left intact.

---

---

Issues: Whether the seized imported goods were correctly declared as GTL Light Paraffin or were liable to be treated as Light Diesel Oil, and whether the seizure could be sustained with a direction for release of the balance quantity.

Analysis: The dispute turned on competing laboratory reports and the effect of the remnant-sample retest by the Central Revenue Control Laboratory, New Delhi. The earlier report from the Customs House Laboratory, Kandla was limited in scope, while the report from the Central Excise and Customs Laboratory, Vadodara indicated diesel-fuel characteristics. The retest by the Central Revenue Control Laboratory, New Delhi, on the other hand, categorically opined that the samples were liquid paraffin, met the requirements of paraffinic diesel fuel, and were other than Automotive Diesel Fuel and Light Diesel Oil. The Court also accepted, at least prima facie, the petitioner's case that the cargo formed part of a commingled import, and noted that the comparable consignments of another importer had already been released.

Conclusion: The goods were treated as GTL Light Paraffin and not Light Diesel Oil, and the balance seized quantity was directed to be released on undertaking and cooperation with the inquiry.

Final Conclusion: The petition succeeded to the extent of securing release of the balance imported goods, while leaving the customs investigation and the respondents' rights in the inquiry intact.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the authoritative retest of the remnant samples establishes that the imported product is not Light Diesel Oil but liquid paraffin of the declared class, continued seizure cannot be justified solely on an unresolved suspicion, and release may be directed on suitable safeguards without prejudicing the ongoing investigation.

---