Rectification for apparent mistakes only: debatable tax explanations cannot be reopened under trade tax rectification powers.

Rectification under Section 22 of the U.P. Trade Tax Act, 1948 is confined to mistakes apparent from the record and cannot be used to decide a debatable issue or one needing detailed reasoning. On the facts, additions relating to leather and cotton thread were sustained because the assessee's own books showed the purchases, making the omission an apparent mistake. The addition relating to cotton was not sustainable in rectification because the assessee offered a specific explanation that the goods had already suffered tax in the hands of a registered dealer, and that explanation was not shown to be patently false or rejectable without evidence. The principle is that only clear, record-based errors can be corrected in rectification.

---

---

Issues: Whether an assessment could be rectified under Section 22 of the U.P. Trade Tax Act, 1948 to levy tax on purchases from unregistered dealers where some additions rested on an admitted omission and another addition depended on a debatable explanation.

Analysis: The scope of rectification under Section 22 is confined to correcting mistakes apparent from the record; a doubtful or debatable question, or one requiring elaborate reasoning, cannot be examined in rectification proceedings. On the facts, the additions relating to leather and cotton thread were sustained because the assessee's own books disclosed the purchases and no plausible dispute survived on those items, so the omission was treated as an apparent mistake. In contrast, the addition relating to cotton could not be sustained in rectification because the assessee had furnished a specific explanation that the cotton had suffered tax in the hands of a registered dealer, and that explanation was neither shown to be patently false nor capable of rejection without evidence.

Conclusion: Rectification was valid for the additions concerning leather and cotton thread, but not for the addition concerning cotton; the assessee succeeded only to that extent.

Ratio Decidendi: A mistake can be rectified under Section 22 only when it is apparent from the record, and an issue that becomes debatable on the assessee's explanation cannot be brought within rectification.

---