Trade discount need not be uniform to qualify for deduction in excise valuation if granted at arm's length.

A genuine trade discount deducted in the ordinary course of business is allowable in fixing wholesale cash price and assessable value under section 4(a) of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944. The High Court noted that the provision treats excise as a levy on manufacture and permits deduction only for trade discount and duty payable on removal, but it does not require the discount to be uniform across all wholesale purchasers. Because the regional discount was a percentage reduction from list price granted at arm's length, it retained the character of trade discount. The excise authorities were therefore not justified in refusing approval of the price lists on the ground of non-uniformity.

---

---

Issues: Whether regional discount, though not uniformly granted to all wholesale purchasers, is deductible as trade discount in determining the wholesale cash price under section 4(a) of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944, and the assessable value for excise duty.

Analysis: The relevant provision treated excise as a levy on manufacture, while section 4 supplied the machinery for valuation on the basis of wholesale cash price. The Explanation to section 4(a) permitted deduction only for trade discount and duty payable at removal, and did not impose any requirement that trade discount must be uniform across all purchasers. Since regional discount was a percentage deduction from list price, granted in the ordinary course of business and at arm's length, it fell within the concept of trade discount. The absence of uniformity did not alter its character, because the true assessable value must reflect the actual manufacturing profit on the consignment concerned and cannot be artificially inflated by ignoring a genuine commercial discount.

Conclusion: Regional discount was a permissible deduction under section 4(a), and the excise authorities were not justified in refusing approval of the price lists on the ground that the discount was not uniformly granted.

Ratio Decidendi: A genuine trade discount deductible under section 4(a) need not be uniform among all wholesale purchasers; if allowed at arm's length in the ordinary course of business, it must be deducted in determining the wholesale cash price and assessable value.

---