Commercial classification of mosquito repellent goods as insecticides governs entry tax where no separate entry exists.

Mosquito repellent, mosquito mats and coils were treated as insecticides and pesticides for classification under Entry 20 of Schedule II to the Madhya Pradesh Entry Tax Act, 1976 because the goods contained insecticidal chemical composition and were understood in commercial parlance as mosquito repellent products with insecticidal properties. In the absence of a separate specific entry for mosquito repellent, the general entry for insecticides and pesticides governed classification, making the goods liable to entry tax under Section 3(1)(b). The note also distinguishes cases where a statute separately lists mosquito repellent, in which event that specific entry would control.

---

---

Issues: Whether mosquito repellent, mosquito mats and coils are classifiable as insecticides and pesticides under Entry 20 of Schedule II to the Madhya Pradesh Entry Tax Act, 1976, so as to attract entry tax under Section 3(1)(b) of that Act.

Analysis: The controversy turned on the true nature of the goods in trade and in law. The products were found to contain insecticidal chemical composition and were understood in commercial parlance as mosquito repellent goods having insecticidal properties. In the absence of any separate specific entry for mosquito repellent under the Madhya Pradesh Entry Tax Act, 1976, the goods were treated as falling within the existing entry for insecticides and pesticides. The reasoning also distinguished situations where a statute contains a separate specific entry for mosquito repellent, in which event that specific entry would govern classification.

Conclusion: The goods are covered by Entry 20 of Schedule II to the Madhya Pradesh Entry Tax Act, 1976 and are liable to entry tax under Section 3(1)(b) of that Act. The answer is against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue.

Final Conclusion: The tax reference was answered in favour of the department, and the classification adopted by the appellate authority was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a product is commercially understood as containing insecticidal properties and the statute contains a specific entry for insecticides and pesticides but no separate entry for mosquito repellent, the product falls under the insecticide entry for tax classification.

---