Tribunal Affirms Revenue Recognition Method for Real Estate Sales

The Tribunal affirmed the CIT(A)'s application of the percentage completion method for sales where registry had been executed, recognizing revenue at Rs. 2,11,38,286/-. It held that significant risks and rewards of ownership had been transferred under plot buyer agreements, applying the method to advances received. The Tribunal directed recognition of revenue for advances to the extent of work completed (45.73%), totaling Rs. 2,03,17,159/-. The Tribunal disposed of the appeals, affirming revenue recognition for executed sale deeds and setting aside the CIT(A)'s income enhancement for advances, directing recognition based on work completed.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Determination of gross profit from sales where registry has been executed.
2. Recognition of revenue on a percentage completion basis for advances received from customers.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Determination of Gross Profit from Sales Where Registry Has Been Executed:

The assessee challenged the CIT(A)'s determination of gross profit at Rs. 1,17,80,367/- against the declared Rs. 1,17,24,318/-, confirming an addition of Rs. 56,049/-. The Revenue contested the reduction of profit from Rs. 2,29,91,672/- to Rs. 1,17,80,367/-.

The assessee follows the "percentage completion method" for revenue recognition. The AO observed that the assessee recognized only part of the sales as revenue and did not offer income for tax on advances received from customers. The AO issued a show-cause notice and subsequently rejected the books of accounts, applying the percentage completion method as per Accounting Standards issued by ICAI.

The CIT(A) noted that the assessee had completed only 45.73% of development work by 31.03.2012 and applied the percentage completion method to the sales where registry had been executed, determining the profit at Rs. 1,17,80,367/-. The CIT(A) stated that revenue should be recognized when the seller has transferred significant risks and rewards of ownership, even if substantial acts remain to be performed.

2. Recognition of Revenue on Percentage Completion Basis for Advances Received from Customers:

The assessee argued that revenue recognition conditions were not satisfied for advances from customers, as significant risks and rewards of ownership had not been transferred. The AO applied the percentage completion method to advances received, determining a profit of Rs. 1,13,22,028/-. The CIT(A) enhanced this amount to Rs. 1,73,71,778/- by considering the gross value of advances and applying the percentage completion method.

The CIT(A) held that the assessee had not applied the percentage completion method to advances received from customers, which was inconsistent with the method claimed to be followed. The CIT(A) concluded that the total contract amount for plots, where plot buyer agreements were executed and substantial advances received, should be considered for computing profit by applying the percentage completion method.

Findings and Conclusions:

The Tribunal affirmed the CIT(A)'s application of the percentage completion method for sales where registry had been executed, recognizing revenue at Rs. 2,11,38,286/-. Regarding advances received from customers, the Tribunal held that the significant risks and rewards of ownership had been transferred under the plot buyer agreements, and the percentage completion method should apply to the advances received.

The Tribunal noted that the assessee's consistent accounting policy of not recognizing revenue on advances was not in consonance with the percentage completion method. The Tribunal directed that revenues to the extent of work completed (45.73%) should be recognized for advances received, amounting to Rs. 2,03,17,159/-.

Disposition:

The Tribunal disposed of the respective grounds of appeal, affirming the CIT(A)'s findings on the recognition of revenue for executed sale deeds and setting aside the CIT(A)'s enhancement of income for advances received from customers, directing the recognition of revenue to the extent of work completed. The appeals of the assessee and the revenue were disposed of with these directions.

---