CENVAT credit on reconstructed bills of entry and office air-conditioners within a factory was upheld without interference.

Reconstructed bills of entry authenticated by Customs were treated as valid duty-paying documents for CENVAT credit, and the Cenvat Credit Rules were read as not prescribing any time limit for availing credit on those documents. Air-conditioners installed in an office within the factory were also treated as goods used in the factory, consistent with the applicable circular. The High Court found the Tribunal's factual and legal conclusions supported by its reasoning and held that no substantial question of law arose, leaving the credit allowance undisturbed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Tribunal's order allowing CENVAT credit on reconstructed bills of entry, documents stated to be over one year old, and air-conditioners installed in the office within the factory called for interference and gave rise to any substantial question of law.

Analysis: The Tribunal had found that the reconstructed bills of entry were authenticated by the Customs authorities and therefore constituted proper duty-paying documents. It also held that the Cenvat Credit Rules did not prescribe any time limit for availing credit on the documents in question. On the air-conditioners, the Tribunal relied on the Central Board circular treating goods used in an office within the factory as used in the factory for the purposes of credit. The High Court found that these factual conclusions were supported by the Tribunal's reasoning and did not warrant interference.

Conclusion: No substantial question of law arose and the Tribunal's allowance of credit was left undisturbed; the appeal failed.

---