2004 (2) TMI 741 - HC - Income Tax

Rental Income from Flat Assessed as 'Income from House Property' Despite Lack of Registered Sale Deed.

Commissioner of Income Tax Versus Kamla Sondhi

The HC ruled in favor of the assessed, determining that rental income from a flat in a multistoreyed building should be assessed under 'Income from house ... - Issues:Interpretation of rental income from a flat in a multistoreyed building under the head 'Income from house property' without legal title acquisition through a registered sale deed.Analysis:The High Court addressed the issue referred by the Tribunal regarding the assessability of rental income from a flat in a multistoreyed building in the hands of the assessed under the head 'Income from house property' despite not having acquired legal title through a registered sale deed. The Court relied on the Supreme Court decision in CIT v. Podar Cement (P) Ltd. [1997] 226 ITR 625(SC) to determine the answer in favor of the assessed and against the revenue. The Supreme Court's decision highlighted that, under the Income Tax Act, the concept of ownership for tax purposes differs from the common law definition. The Court emphasized that for income tax purposes, an owner is considered as a person entitled to receive income from the property in their own right, irrespective of legal title acquisition through formalities like the Transfer of Property Act or Registration Act.Therefore, based on the Supreme Court's interpretation and the objective of the Income Tax Act to tax income, the High Court concluded that the rental income from the flat in a multistoreyed building should be assessed in favor of the assessed, even without the legal title acquisition through a registered sale deed. The Court's decision aligned with the broader understanding of ownership for tax purposes, emphasizing the entitlement to income as a defining factor rather than strict legal formalities.