As-is-where-is sale of secured asset does not imply duty to deliver vacant possession absent an express stipulation.

A secured asset sold on an as-is-where-is basis does not, by itself, create an implied duty on the secured creditor to remove occupants and deliver vacant physical possession after issuance of the sale certificate. The auction notice and sale terms govern the parties' rights, and where the purchaser bids with notice of existing occupation, the principle of caveat emptor applies. Encumbrance was treated as limited to burdens legally ascertainable or discoverable on inspection, unless the sale notice expressly provides otherwise. The Court distinguished SARFAESI possession cases that did not involve an as-is-where-is sale and held that no enforceable duty arose to hand over vacant possession.

---

---

Issues: Whether, after purchase of a secured asset sold on as-is-where-is basis and issuance of the sale certificate, the secured creditor was under a legal duty to hand over vacant and peaceful physical possession to the auction purchasers and whether a mandamus could be issued for that purpose.

Analysis: The auction notice and sale certificate governed the rights of the parties. The secured asset was expressly sold on as-is-where-is basis, and the purchaser participated with notice of the existing occupation and attendant disadvantages. In such a sale, the term encumbrance was held to include only burdens discoverable on inspection or otherwise legally ascertainable, and not an implied promise that the secured creditor would clear occupants unless the notice or terms of sale so provided. Decisions dealing with delivery of possession after sale under the SARFAESI framework were distinguished because they did not involve a sale expressly on as-is-where-is basis. The principle of caveat emptor applied, and the Court held that, on these facts, the respondents had no enforceable duty to secure and hand over vacant physical possession to the purchasers.

Conclusion: The respondents were not bound to deliver vacant and peaceful physical possession of the secured asset, and no mandamus could be issued against them for that relief.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a secured asset is sold on as-is-where-is basis and the purchaser bids with knowledge of the existing occupation, the secured creditor is not, absent an express stipulation, under a legal duty to deliver vacant physical possession after issuance of the sale certificate.

---