Railway coach LED luminaires fall under lighting fittings, not railway parts, under tariff exclusions and GST rate entries.

LED luminaires manufactured for passenger coaches of Indian Railways were analysed under the tariff exclusion scheme in Section XVII. Because electrical machinery and equipment of Chapter 85, and lamps and lighting fittings of heading 9405, are specifically excluded from treatment as railway parts or accessories, their design for exclusive railway use did not support classification under Chapter 8607. The goods were therefore classified under Chapter 9405, and the applicable GST followed the rate entries for that heading in the relevant Central and Uttar Pradesh notifications, attracting 6% CGST and 6% SGST.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether LED based luminaires manufactured for passenger coaches of Indian Railways were classifiable under Chapter 8607 as parts of railway rolling-stock or under Chapter 9405 as lamps and lighting fittings; (ii) What rate of GST applied to such goods under the relevant Central and State rate notifications.

Issue (i): Whether LED based luminaires manufactured for passenger coaches of Indian Railways were classifiable under Chapter 8607 as parts of railway rolling-stock or under Chapter 9405 as lamps and lighting fittings.

Analysis: The exclusionary scheme of Section XVII was applied. Electrical machinery or equipment of Chapter 85 and lamps or lighting fittings of heading 9405 are specifically taken out of the meaning of parts and accessories, even if they are identifiable for use with railway vehicles. The fact that the goods were designed for and supplied only to railway coaches did not override the tariff exclusions. On that basis, the claimed classification under Chapter 8607 was rejected.

Conclusion: The goods were held classifiable under Chapter 9405 and not under Chapter 8607.

Issue (ii): What rate of GST applied to such goods under the relevant Central and State rate notifications.

Analysis: Once classified under Chapter 9405, the applicable rate followed the entries for that heading in the rate notifications. The authority applied the Schedule-II entries of the Central and Uttar Pradesh notifications to goods classifiable under Chapter 9405.

Conclusion: The goods were held liable to GST at 6% CGST and 6% SGST.

Final Conclusion: The advance ruling went against the applicant on classification and tax rate, with the goods treated as lighting fittings under Chapter 9405 and taxed accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods specifically designed for railway use remain classifiable under their own tariff heading when the relevant section notes expressly exclude electrical equipment and lighting fittings from treatment as railway parts or accessories.

---