1963 (8) TMI 68 - HC - Income Tax

High Court rules taxes not deductible from reserve for capital computation under Business Profits Tax Act

The High Court ruled in favor of the assessee-company, stating that taxes paid should not be deducted from the taxation reserve account for capital ... - Issues Involved:1. Permissibility of deducting taxes paid from the taxation reserve account for computing capital under the Business Profits Tax Act.2. Classification and treatment of advance tax payments in the context of reserves.3. System of accounting and its impact on the treatment of tax payments and reserves.Issue-wise Detailed Analysis:1. Permissibility of Deducting Taxes Paid from the Taxation Reserve Account:The core issue is whether the Income Tax department can deduct taxes paid from the taxation reserve account when computing the capital of the assessee-company under the Business Profits Tax Act. The assessee-company maintained a 'taxation reserve account' funded by profit appropriations and a 'taxes paid account' for taxes paid from available funds. The Income Tax Officer set off the taxes paid against the balances in the 'taxation reserve account,' resulting in a net figure for capital computation. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner upheld this decision, emphasizing that the reserve should reflect only the net figure after tax payments. However, the Tribunal disagreed, stating that the taxation reserve was built from past profits and should be treated as a general reserve. The Tribunal concluded that payments from the 'taxes paid account' should not deplete the 'taxation reserve account,' as the reserve was not specifically earmarked for tax payments. The High Court upheld the Tribunal's view, stating that the system of accounting adopted by the assessee-company was justified and consistent with accounting principles. The court ruled that the amounts paid from the 'taxes paid account' should not be deducted from the 'taxation reserve account' for capital computation.2. Classification and Treatment of Advance Tax Payments:The assessee-company argued that advance tax payments should not be deducted from the taxation reserve. The Tribunal accepted this contention, noting that advance tax payments were made from unappropriated funds and not from the reserve. The High Court agreed, emphasizing that advance tax payments under section 18A of the Income Tax Act were made under statutory compulsion and did not constitute part of the reserve. The court cited accounting principles and previous case law to support its view that advance tax payments should be treated as payments on account and should not deplete the reserve. The court concluded that advance tax payments should not be deducted from the 'taxation reserve account' for capital computation.3. System of Accounting and Its Impact on the Treatment of Tax Payments and Reserves:The court examined the system of accounting adopted by the assessee-company, which treated advance tax payments as advances until assessments were finalized. The court found this system justified, as it allowed for accurate accounting of tax liabilities. The court noted that the assessee-company maintained separate accounts for advance tax payments and the taxation reserve, and that the reserve was intended to meet tax liabilities after final assessments. The court concluded that the system of accounting adopted by the assessee-company was consistent with accounting principles and should be respected by the Income Tax department.Conclusion:The High Court ruled in favor of the assessee-company, stating that the amounts paid from the 'taxes paid account' should not be deducted from the 'taxation reserve account' for capital computation. The court emphasized that advance tax payments should not deplete the reserve and upheld the system of accounting adopted by the assessee-company. The court's answers to the reframed questions were as follows:1. Question No. 1: In the negative.2. Question No. 2: In the affirmative.3. Question No. 3: Not pressed and therefore not answered.The Commissioner was ordered to pay the costs of the reference to the assessee-company.