Revisional order refusing interference is not prejudicial to the assessee and cannot support further revision under tax law.

An order by the Commissioner under section 34 of the Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1955, that merely declines to interfere with an assessment does not qualify as an order enhancing the assessment or otherwise prejudicial to the assessee. The statutory scheme provides a separate appeal from the original assessment and a further appeal to the Tribunal, while the revisional power under section 34 is limited by the second proviso, which excludes orders refusing interference from the category of prejudicial orders. On that construction, no revision lies under section 54 against such a refusal, because the assessee is not placed in a worse position than under the original order.

---

---

Issues: Whether a revision to the High Court under section 54 of the Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1955 lies against an order of the Commissioner under section 34 declining to interfere with the assessment order and, in particular, whether such an order is an order "enhancing the assessment or otherwise prejudicial" to the assessee.

Analysis: The statutory scheme provided a specific appeal against the original partition-assessment order, followed by further appeal to the Tribunal, while section 34 conferred revisional power on the Commissioner. The second proviso to section 34 expressly stated that an order declining to interfere is not to be deemed prejudicial to the assessee. Reading section 54 in that context, and applying the settled construction placed on analogous provisions by the Privy Council and High Courts, the Court held that an order merely refusing interference does not put the assessee in a worse position than that created by the original subordinate order and therefore does not satisfy the statutory requirement of a prejudicial order.

Conclusion: No revision lay under section 54 against the Commissioner's order declining to interfere under section 34, and the petition was not maintainable.

Ratio Decidendi: An order of revisional authority that merely declines to interfere, without worsening the assessee's position, is not an order enhancing the assessment or otherwise prejudicial to the assessee for the purpose of further revision or reference.

---