2015 (12) TMI 253 - AT - Central Excise

Tribunal grants unconditional stay on Cenvat credit and duty demand, penalties

M/s Ganpati Rollings Pvt. Ltd. & Shri Sushil Kumar Jain Versus CCE, Delhi - I

The Tribunal granted an unconditional stay on both the Cenvat credit demand and duty demand, along with associated penalties, in favor of the appellant ... Waiver of pre deposit - Duty demand - Denial of CENVAT Credit - Fraudulent credit - Bogus invoices - under reported the production of copper rods by inflating the power consumption - Held that:- Tribunal in respect of the case against M/s V.K. Metal Works has vide stay order has waived the requirement of pre-deposit of the duty demand, interest and penalty and had stayed its recovery by taking a prima facie view that the above-mentioned allegation against them by issuing bogus invoices for copper ingots without manufacturing any activity prima facie is not sustainable. - appellant have prima facie case in respect of the Cenvat credit demand of ₹ 5,50,50,489/- and hence in respect of this Cenvat credit demand unconditional stay has to be granted. Appellant had given the reasons for this fluctuation and according to them this fluctuation is due to power break down or fluctuation in electric voltage resulting in breakdown of manufacturing process resulting in cooling of furnace which requires more consumption of power for re-heating. Prima facie, we find that these factors have not been considered and the Commissioner has arbitrarily adopted the power consumption figure of 346 units per MT as the norm for the entire period. In our prima facie view estimating production on this basis would not be correct when there is absolutely no evidence of unaccounted purchase of raw material. - Stay granted. Issues:1. Allegation of taking Cenvat credit based on bogus invoices.2. Allegation of underreporting production by inflating power consumption.Analysis:1. The appellant company was accused of taking Cenvat credit amounting to Rs. 5,50,50,489 based on alleged bogus invoices of copper ingots from M/s V.K. Metal Works, Jammu. The Commissioner confirmed this demand along with penalties. The appellant argued that the same allegation against M/s V.K. Metal Works was not sustainable as per a Tribunal stay order, which also considered the existence of M/s Kanpur Kashmir Roadways. The Tribunal found a prima facie case in favor of the appellant and granted an unconditional stay on the Cenvat credit demand.2. The second allegation against the appellant was underreporting production by inflating power consumption, leading to a duty demand of Rs. 32,06,93,486. The Commissioner adopted a power consumption norm of 346 units per MT, disregarding fluctuations due to power breakdowns and voltage fluctuations. The appellant contended that this norm was arbitrary and did not consider valid reasons for power consumption variations. They cited legal precedents where allegations based solely on power consumption norms were deemed unsustainable. The Tribunal agreed with the appellant, finding that the duty demand was not sustainable due to lack of evidence of unaccounted raw material purchase and arbitrary adoption of power consumption figures. Therefore, the Tribunal waived the pre-deposit requirement for the duty demand, interest, and penalties, allowing a stay on recovery.In conclusion, the Tribunal granted an unconditional stay on both the Cenvat credit demand and duty demand, along with associated penalties, in favor of the appellant company and its director, based on the lack of sustainable evidence and arbitrary adoption of norms by the Commissioner.