Wide arbitration clause in composite joint venture transaction supported SIAC arbitration and defeated interim injunction relief.

A wide arbitration clause covering disputes arising out of, in relation to, or in connection with a joint venture agreement was held to extend to later instruments executed in furtherance of that transaction. The court treated the joint venture agreement, debenture subscription arrangement, and deed of adherence as a composite commercial structure, so the valuation and conversion disputes over CCDs were prima facie within the arbitration agreement. It also noted that the foreign-seated arbitration framework and the tribunal's competence to rule on jurisdiction militated against interim civil court interference. Injunctive relief restraining the SIAC arbitration was therefore refused.

---

---

Issues: Whether the plaintiffs were entitled to an injunction restraining the defendant from proceeding with SIAC arbitration on the ground that the disputes were outside the scope of the arbitration agreement and that the Court should restrain the arbitral proceedings.

Analysis: The dispute arose out of a joint venture arrangement in which the arbitration clause covered disputes arising out of, in relation to, or in connection with the agreement and its implementation. The Court treated the joint venture agreement, the debenture subscription arrangement, and the deed of adherence as part of a composite transaction, holding that the later documents were executed in furtherance of the principal agreement and could not be read in isolation. Since the arbitral clause was wide and the controversy concerned valuation and conversion of CCDs created under the joint venture structure, the Court held that the dispute was prima facie within the arbitration clause. The Court also noted that the foreign-seated arbitration framework and the arbitral tribunal's competence to rule on jurisdiction weighed against civil court interference at the interim stage.

Conclusion: The plaintiffs were not entitled to an injunction, and the arbitration was permitted to proceed.

---