Refund claim cannot bypass an unchallenged assessment order once finality has attached.

A refund claim cannot be used to indirectly reopen an assessment that has attained finality. Where the assessee did not challenge the assessment order by appeal, the Tribunal held that the refund application was barred, relying on binding Supreme Court decisions. The absence of an appeal against the assessment order was therefore fatal to maintainability, and the refund claim was rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether a refund claim is maintainable when the assessment order has not been challenged by way of appeal.

Analysis: The Tribunal applied the settled principle that a refund claim cannot be used to indirectly challenge an assessment which has attained finality. Since the assessment order had not been appealed against, the refund application was held to be barred in view of the binding Supreme Court decisions on the point.

Conclusion: The refund claim was not maintainable in the absence of an appeal against the assessment order, and the appeal was dismissed.

---