Export duty exemption turned on re-test results showing Fe content below the threshold, and remand was rejected.

Export duty exemption under Notification No. 62/2007-Cus. depended on whether the re-test established Fe content below 62%, and the recorded re-test results of 61.0% and 60.8% satisfied that condition. On that basis, the exporter was treated as eligible for the exemption, making the differential duty demand unsustainable. Remand was declined because the decisive re-test outcome was already on record and no useful purpose would be served by sending the matter back.

---

---

Issues: Whether the exporter was entitled to exemption from export duty under Notification No. 62/2007-Cus. on the basis of the re-test result showing Fe content below 62%, and whether remand was necessary.

Analysis: The re-test had been duly permitted and the result communicated by the customs authorities showed Fe content of 61.0% and 60.8% for the consignments. On that factual basis, the condition in the notification stood satisfied and the exporter became eligible for the exemption. As the decisive re-test result was already on record and no useful purpose would be served by sending the matter back, remand was declined.

Conclusion: The exporter was held entitled to the benefit of the exemption notification, the demand of differential duty was unsustainable, and the request for remand was rejected.

---