Rule 4 compliance is not required before a section 4 land acquisition notification, clarifying the preliminary statutory stage.

Compliance with Rule 4 of the Land Acquisition (Companies) Rules, 1963 is not a mandatory pre-condition to issue a section 4 notification under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The statutory scheme treats section 4 as the preliminary stage requiring only the government's view that land is needed or likely to be needed, while Rule 4 and the related reports and agreement under section 41 concern the later section 6 declaration stage. The compensation rule in section 23, which values land by reference to the date of the section 4 notification, also supports this reading. Earlier contrary observations were not treated as binding.

---

---

Issues: Whether compliance with rule 4 of the Land Acquisition (Companies) Rules, 1963 is mandatory before issuing a notification under section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 in acquisitions for a company.

Analysis: The statutory scheme distinguishes between the preliminary stage under section 4 and the stage of declaration under section 6. Section 4 requires only that it appears to the appropriate government that land is needed or likely to be needed, whereas section 6 requires governmental satisfaction after considering the relevant reports and the agreement under section 41. Rule 4, by its text and structure, regulates the matters to be considered before declaration under section 6 and does not prohibit the issuance of a section 4 notification before the enquiry under rule 4 is held. The compensation framework under section 23, which fixes market value with reference to the date of publication of the section 4 notification, also supports this construction. Earlier observations suggesting a contrary view were treated as not laying down a binding rule on the point.

Conclusion: Compliance with rule 4 is not a mandatory pre-condition for issuing a notification under section 4. The High Court's view to the contrary was set aside, and the matter was remitted for decision on the remaining grounds.

---