Excisability of repair scrap: MS scrap from maintenance work was held non-excisable and duty on removal was unsustainable.

MS scrap generated from steel plates, angles and channels used for repair and maintenance of plant and machinery, and not arising from any manufacturing process, was treated as non-excisable. On that basis, the provisions governing duty on removal of excisable goods from the factory were held inapplicable, and the demand under Section 11A could not be sustained. The Revenue's reliance on a cited precedent was distinguished because that case concerned reversal of Cenvat credit on waste and scrap, not duty on removal of scrap. The duty demand on removal of the MS scrap was therefore held unsustainable and the assessee succeeded.

---

---

Issues: Whether MS scrap generated from steel items used for repair and maintenance of plant and machinery was excisable and liable to central excise duty on removal from the factory, and whether the demand could be sustained under Rule 4(1), Rule 8(1) and Section 11A.

Analysis: The scrap was found to have arisen from MS plates, angles and channels used in repair and maintenance, and not from any manufacturing process. On that basis, the scrap was not treated as manufactured excisable goods of the appellant. The provisions governing payment of duty on removal of excisable goods from the factory were therefore held inapplicable. The decision cited on behalf of the Revenue was distinguished because it concerned reversal of cenvat credit on waste and scrap, whereas the present dispute was about duty on removal of scrap. The attempt to confirm duty demand under Section 11A was also held to be unjustified.

Conclusion: The duty demand on removal of the MS scrap was not sustainable, and the appeal was allowed in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Scrap generated from materials used for repair and maintenance, without arising from a manufacturing process, is not excisable goods liable to duty on removal, and demand provisions applicable to excisable goods cannot be invoked to sustain such duty demand.

---