Classification of imported goods as fat liquor denied exemption where testing showed composition beyond sulphonated fish oil.

Imported goods were held, on testing, to be classifiable as fat liquor under CTH 34.03 rather than sulphonated fish oil under CTH 34.02 because their composition contained ingredients beyond sulphonated fish oil. The same classification approach was applied as in an earlier Tribunal decision on identical goods, and that reasoning was followed. On that basis, the exemption claimed under Notification No. 17/2001 was not available, because the goods fell within the fat liquor heading and not the notified product description.

---

---

Issues: Whether the imported goods were classifiable as fat liquor under CTH 34.03 or as sulphonated fish oil under CTH 34.02, and whether the exemption under Notification No. 17/2001 was available.

Analysis: The imported goods were found on testing to be fat liquor and not sulphonated fish oil. The composition showed the presence of ingredients beyond sulphonated fish oil, bringing the goods within the classification adopted for fat liquor under CTH 34.03. The issue had already been settled by an earlier Tribunal decision on identical goods, and the same reasoning was followed. Since the goods were correctly classified under CTH 34.03, the claimed exemption was not available.

Conclusion: The classification under CTH 34.03 was upheld and the denial of exemption was sustained against the assessee.

---