Legal expenses to resist a winding-up petition may qualify as revenue deduction when incurred to preserve business continuity

Legal expenses bona fide incurred to resist a compulsory winding-up petition are revenue expenditure if they are wholly and exclusively laid out for the business. Where the expenditure is directed to preserving the company's ability to continue trading, and does not create a new asset or improve a capital asset, it is treated as incurred to protect the business structure rather than for capital purposes. On that basis, the costs of defending proceedings threatening the continued existence of the undertaking are admissible as a business deduction.

---

---

Issues: Whether the legal expenses incurred by a company in defending a petition for compulsory winding up of the company were an admissible deduction in computing business profits under section 10(2)(xv) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922.

Analysis: The governing test is whether the expenditure was bona fide incurred wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the business. Expenditure incurred to protect or preserve business assets, stock-in-trade, or the ability to carry on business has been treated as revenue expenditure where it does not bring into existence a new asset or improve an existing capital asset. The same principle applies where the threat is to the whole business undertaking, since expenditure to resist seizure or destruction of the business structure is still directed to enabling the company to carry on and earn profits. A winding-up petition seeks to bring the company's business to an end and to realise and distribute its assets; expenses incurred in resisting such a petition are therefore incurred to preserve the company's capacity to continue trading.

Conclusion: The expenditure was laid out wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the business and was an admissible deduction under section 10(2)(xv) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922.

Ratio Decidendi: Legal expenses bona fide incurred to resist proceedings that threaten the continued existence of the business and are directed to preserving the company's ability to carry on and earn profits are revenue expenditure allowable as business deduction, so long as they do not create or improve a capital asset.

---