Paper classification principle: adhesive-backed post-it paper remains paper under an inclusive entry, not residuary goods.

Post-it paper was held to remain classifiable as paper where, in ordinary and commercial understanding, its essential character continued to be that of paper despite being cut into sizes and having adhesive on one side. An inclusive entry for "paper of all kinds" was construed broadly to cover the commodity, and the residuary provision applied only where no specific entry covered the goods. The commodity was therefore brought within the specific paper entry and excluded from residuary taxation.

---

---

Issues: Whether post-it-paper falls within Entry 69(i) of the Third Schedule to the Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003 as paper of all kinds, or whether it is a distinct commercial commodity liable to tax under the residuary provision.

Analysis: Entry 69(i) is an inclusive entry covering paper of all kinds and like articles, excluding only photographic paper. The goods in question were imported as paper, cut into sizes, and used as writing or flag paper with adhesive on one side. The form in which paper is presented is not decisive, and its classification depends on its ordinary and popular understanding. The use of adhesive on one side and the process of cutting it into pieces did not change its essential character as paper. The residuary provision applies only when the goods do not fall within a specific entry, and Entry 69(i) was sufficiently wide to cover the commodity.

Conclusion: Post-it-paper falls under Entry 69(i) and is taxable at 4%. It does not fall under the residuary provision at 12.5%.

Ratio Decidendi: A commodity remains classifiable as paper when, in popular and commercial understanding, its essential character continues to be that of paper and it is covered by an inclusive entry for paper of all kinds.

---