Business deduction for robbery loss upheld where cash carriage was an essential part of statutory cane payment operations.

Robbery loss of cash carried to a purchasing centre for payment to cane growers was treated as deductible in computing taxable income because the despatch of cash was an essential incident of the assessee's business under the Bihar Sugar Factories Control Act, 1937 and Rules, 1938. The expression "profits and gains" in section 10(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1922 was construed in a commercial sense, so deductions necessary to determine real business profit were not confined to the specific items listed in section 10(2). The earlier departmental authority was distinguished as not creating an absolute bar to deduction of theft losses. The loss was therefore allowed as a business deduction.

---

---

Issues: Whether the loss of Rs. 35,000, robbed while being taken to a purchasing centre for payment to cane growers under the statutory sugarcane control regime, was deductible in computing the assessee's total income.

Analysis: The payment of cane price was governed by the Bihar Sugar Factories Control Act, 1937 and the Bihar Sugar Factories Control Rules, 1938, which required the assessee to maintain purchasing centres, weighment arrangements, and timely payment to cultivators. On those facts, the despatch of cash was an essential part of the business operations, and the robbery-loss sprang directly from the statutory necessity of carrying out that business. The expression "profits and gains" in section 10(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1922 was to be understood in a commercial sense, and deductions necessary to ascertain real business profit were not confined to the items expressly enumerated in section 10(2). The earlier decision relied on by the department was distinguished as not laying down an absolute rule against deduction of theft-loss in all cases.

Conclusion: The loss was deductible in computing the assessee's taxable income, and the question was answered in the affirmative, in favour of the assessee.

---