Repeated tax audits after completed audit assessment are impermissible where reopening must proceed under the statutory escape-assessment mechanism.

Repeated tax audits for the same tax period are impermissible once an audit assessment under section 42 of the Orissa Value Added Tax Act, 2004 has been completed. Section 41 authorises audit selection and conduct, while section 43 provides the distinct reopening mechanism where turnover has escaped assessment or under-assessment exists, subject to safeguards and limitation. After completion of an audit assessment for a period, the authority becomes functus officio for a second audit assessment on that same period. The result is that a fresh audit notice for the same tax period cannot be used to bypass the statutory reopening scheme, and the impugned notice was quashed.

---

---

Issues: Whether repeated tax audits under section 41 of the Orissa Value Added Tax Act, 2004 could be undertaken for the same tax period after an audit assessment under section 42 of that Act had already been completed.

Analysis: Section 41 empowers selection and conduct of tax audit, while section 42 provides for audit assessment on the basis of the audit report. Section 43 separately enables reopening where turnover has escaped assessment or there is under-assessment, and it provides its own safeguards and limitation period. Once an audit assessment for a particular period is completed under section 42, the assessing authority becomes functus officio for that period so far as a second audit assessment under the same provision is concerned. Permitting repeated tax audits for the same period would render the statutory scheme under section 43 redundant and would allow the Department to bypass the specific reopening mechanism and limitation prescribed by the Act and Rules.

Conclusion: Repeated tax audits and fresh audit assessments for the same tax period were held impermissible after completion of an audit assessment under section 42, and the impugned notice was quashed in favour of the assessee.

---