2006 (9) TMI 519 - HC - VAT and Sales Tax

Court Upholds Taxability of Air-Conditioning Plant Installation Contract

Voltas Ltd. Versus State of Gujarat

Voltas Ltd. Versus State of Gujarat - [2007] 5 VST 504 (Guj) Issues Involved:1. Classification of the works contract for fabrication and installation of air-conditioning plants under the Gujarat Sales Tax Act, 1969.2. Determination of the applicable tax rate under the relevant entries of the Schedule to the notification issued under section 55A of the Act.Issue-wise Detailed Analysis:1. Classification of Works Contract:The core issue was whether the works contract for the fabrication and installation of air-conditioning plants should be classified under entry 2 or entry 5 of the Schedule to the notification dated October 18, 1993, issued under section 55A of the Gujarat Sales Tax Act, 1969. Entry 2 pertains to the 'installation of air-conditioners and A.C. coolers' with a tax rate of 15%, while entry 5 pertains to the 'fabrication and installation of plant and machinery' with a tax rate of 5%.2. Determination of Applicable Tax Rate:The Tribunal had held that the works contract for air-conditioning plants falls under entry 2 and is taxable at 15%. The company argued that the term 'air-conditioners' in entry 2 connotes room or window air-conditioners and not large air-conditioning plants, which should fall under entry 5. The Deputy Commissioner and the Tribunal both concluded that the air-conditioning plant is covered by entry 2, as it involves the installation of a system that controls temperature, humidity, and air purity, similar to air-conditioners and A.C. coolers.Detailed Judgment Analysis:Background:M/s. Voltas Limited, engaged in the design, supply, and installation of air-conditioning plants, considered these activities as indivisible works contracts. The company sought clarification on whether the tax rate for their works contract should be 5% under entry 5 or 15% under entry 2 of the Schedule to the notification.Tribunal's Findings:The Tribunal observed that the installation of air-conditioning plants involves the production of cooling air, unlike simple plant and machinery installations. It emphasized that if the government intended to provide a separate benefit for air-conditioning plants, it would have created a distinct entry. Therefore, the Tribunal concluded that entry 2, which specifically mentions air-conditioners and A.C. coolers, includes air-conditioning plants.Arguments by the Assessee:The assessee contended that 'air-conditioners' in entry 2 should be interpreted to mean room or window air-conditioners, and not comprehensive air-conditioning plants. They argued that the fabrication and installation of air-conditioning plants require detailed planning and layout, fitting more appropriately under entry 5.Arguments by the Revenue:The Revenue argued that air-conditioning plants function similarly to air-conditioners and A.C. coolers by controlling temperature, humidity, and air purity. They emphasized that the notification should be construed strictly, and in case of doubt, in favor of the Revenue. They asserted that the air-conditioning plant falls under entry 2 due to its functional similarity with air-conditioners and A.C. coolers.Court's Analysis:The court referred to dictionary definitions and industry standards to conclude that air-conditioning plants and air-conditioners share fundamental similarities in controlling air conditions. The court noted that the basic components and functions of air-conditioning plants are akin to those of room or window air-conditioners, albeit on a larger scale.Conclusion:The court upheld the Tribunal's view that the works contract for the installation of air-conditioning plants falls under entry 2 of the Schedule to the notification, making it taxable at 15%. The court emphasized that the specific entry for air-conditioners and A.C. coolers prevails over the general entry for plant and machinery. The reference was answered in favor of the Revenue, and the Special Civil Application was disposed of accordingly, with the interim relief vacated.