Medicinal preparation classification prevails where ayurvedic products are recognised under drug law, despite incidental toiletry use.

Classification of Vicco Vajradanthi paste and powder and Vicco turmeric cream for sales tax turned on their real character, not dictionary meaning alone. The analysis emphasised that products manufactured under drug licences, treated as ayurvedic drugs under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940, and recognised by competent authorities are to be viewed in their commercial and statutory setting. Their incidental use for oral or bodily cleanliness did not change their essential nature as medicinal preparations rather than toilet articles, and the tax classification was correspondingly in favour of the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether Vicco Vajradanthi paste and powder and Vicco turmeric cream were classifiable as medicinal and pharmaceutical preparations or as toilet articles for sales tax purposes.

Analysis: The relevant entries had to be construed in their popular and commercial sense, but the true nature of the goods could not be determined by dictionary meaning alone when later statutory and technical material showed that the products were manufactured under drug licences, treated as ayurvedic drugs under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940, and examined by competent authorities. The Court noted that earlier decisions treating dentifrices as toilet articles were based on the material then available and did not consider the subsequent legal regime for ayurvedic drugs or the expert and departmental treatment of these products. The Court held that the decisive consideration was the real character of the goods, their composition, their classification under drug law, and their accepted use as medicinal preparations rather than their incidental use for oral or bodily cleanliness.

Conclusion: The products were medicinal preparations and not toilet articles; the revisional order could not stand.

Final Conclusion: The assessee succeeded and the appellate authority's order restoring the original assessment was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a product is manufactured and recognized as a drug or medicinal preparation under the applicable drug law, its incidental use for toiletry does not alter its essential character for tax classification.

---