Separate penalties for false return and non-filing of returns may apply for distinct statutory defaults.

A dealer's filing of a false return for one quarter and failure to file returns for the remaining quarters constituted separate statutory defaults. Penalty under section 43(1) applied to the false return, while penalty under section 17(3) applied to the non-filing of returns for the other periods. The two penalties addressed different breaches and did not overlap merely because they arose within the same assessment period. The Tribunal's view that no penalty under section 43(1) could be levied was rejected, and distinct liability for each default was affirmed.

---

---

Issues: Whether penalty under section 43(1) of the M.P. General Sales Tax Act, 1958, could be levied where a dealer had filed a false return for one quarter and had not filed returns for the remaining quarters.

Analysis: The facts found and admitted showed two distinct defaults: the dealer filed a return for one quarter which was found to be false, and no returns were filed for the remaining three quarters. Penalty under section 17(3) was attracted to the non-filing of returns for the three quarters, while penalty under section 43(1) was attracted to the filing of a false return for the first quarter. The two penalties related to different defaults and there was no overlap merely because both arose in the same assessment period.

Conclusion: The Tribunal was not justified in holding that no penalty under section 43(1) could be levied. Penalty under section 43(1) was leviable for filing a false return, in addition to penalty for non-filing of returns under section 17(3).

Final Conclusion: The reference was answered against the assessee and in support of the Revenue on the distinct liability to penalty for a false return apart from liability for failure to furnish returns.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a dealer commits separate statutory defaults of filing a false return and omitting to file returns for other periods, penalties may be imposed independently for each distinct default under the relevant provisions.

---