Commercial identity test for taxing entries: fallen babul tree wood was treated as timber, not exempt firewood.

Babul wood purchased as a fallen tree cart-load was treated as timber, not firewood, because taxing entries were construed in their popular and commercial sense. The commodity consisted of the whole tree with trunk and branches and had not been chopped or otherwise processed into fuel-sized pieces. Firewood was regarded as wood prepared for fuel, while timber retained its character until transformed by manufacture into a distinct commercial article. The court therefore held that the goods did not fall within the firewood exemption and were taxable as timber under the relevant sales tax entry.

---

---

Issues: Whether babul wood purchased in the form of a fallen tree cart-load was firewood exempt under entry 19 of Schedule A or timber taxable under entry 32 of Schedule C of the Bombay Sales Tax Act, 1959.

Analysis: The entries were interpreted according to the settled rule that words in a taxing statute, where not specially defined, must be construed in their popular and commercial sense as understood in ordinary trade. On the facts, the commodity purchased was the entire fallen babul tree as a cart-load, consisting of trunk, twigs and other parts, and had not undergone chopping or any other process converting it into a different commercial commodity. Firewood is wood prepared for fuel, whereas timber retains its character until it is reduced by a manufacturing process into fuel-sized pieces. The fact that babul wood may be used both as timber and as firewood did not alter the character of the actual commodity purchased.

Conclusion: The purchase was of timber and not firewood. It did not fall within entry 19 of Schedule A, and it fell within entry 32 of Schedule C. The question whether it was firewood was answered in the negative and the question whether it was timber was answered in the affirmative, in favour of Revenue.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a taxing entry is not defined, the true character of the goods must be determined by their commercial identity in common parlance, and a commodity retains its original character until it is transformed by a manufacturing process into a distinct marketable article.

---