Modvat credit for duty-paid inputs was upheld despite invoice misdescription and partial use outside the main factory premises.

Modvat credit remained admissible where duty-paid inputs were received and used in an integrated manufacturing process, even though the invoice named one unit while the inputs were actually handled by another unit. The invoice misdescription was treated as a curable technical defect and did not defeat credit eligibility, because there was no dispute that the inputs were duty paid and were used in the manufacture of final excisable goods. Partial use of inputs outside the main factory premises also did not by itself disqualify credit where the manufacturing chain remained continuous. The denial of credit and the penalty were accordingly set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether Modvat credit was admissible where the duty-paying invoices mentioned the name of one unit while the inputs were actually received and used in the manufacturing operations of another unit, and where part of the input use occurred outside the main factory premises.

Analysis: The credit was denied only because the invoices bore the name of the Andheri unit, though the inputs were received at the Ghatkoper unit and were used in the manufacture of final excisable goods through a split manufacturing process between the two units. The indication of the Andheri unit on the invoices was treated as a curable technical defect. It was also found that there was no dispute that the inputs were duty paid and were used in the manufacture of final products. The reasoning followed the principle that inputs do not lose credit eligibility merely because part of the manufacturing process or intermediate use takes place outside the main factory, so long as the resultant goods are received and used in the manufacturing chain.

Conclusion: Modvat credit was admissible and could not be denied on the ground of the invoice description or partial use of inputs outside the main factory.

Final Conclusion: The denial of credit and the penalty were set aside, and the assessee obtained the claimed relief.

Ratio Decidendi: A minor technical defect in the duty-paying document, or partial use of inputs outside the main factory in an integrated manufacturing process, does not disentitle Modvat credit where the inputs are duty paid and are used in the manufacture of final excisable goods.

---